Thoughts about How Best to Help our Colleagues in this Crisis
Dr. Michael Blumenfeld, MD, FACLP, New York Medical College, Valhalla, NY, provides commentary about supporting medical providers on the front lines. Submitted March 26, 2020.
PDF: Michael Blumenfeld on caring for colleagues in the Covid-19 crisis.pdf
Medical College of Wisconsin Mental Health Interventions for Healthcare Workers
Drs. Julie Owen, MD and Deepa Pawar, MD, MPH, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin submit multiple resources for aid in supporting our colleagues providing crisis care. Submitted March 27, 2020.
Med Coll of Wisc Mental Health Interventions to Support Healthcare Workers 032720.pdf
Using Balint Groups to Aid Hospital Providers During the COVID-19 Outbreak
Dr. Damir Huremović, MD, MPP, FAPA, FACLP, Department of Psychiatry, North Shore University Hospital, Northwell Health, Inc., Manhasset, NY, offers thoughts on Balint groups that they are starting to use to support medical providers. Submitted March 29, 2020.
Balint groups to aid hospital providers in the COVID crisis 032920.pdf
Dr. Huremović offers further thoughts about how administrative supports can decrease stress for providers. Submitted March 31, 2020.
Meta-liaison – A Cardinal Link in Preventing Provider Burnout and Psychological Trauma 033120.pdf
Support for Staff Wellbeing at the Oxford Psychological Medicine Centre
Drs. Michael Sharpe, MD, and Simon Prangnell, PhD, Oxford University Hospitals, Oxford, UK, describe a three-tier model of support for medical colleagues. Submitted April 15, 2020.
Psychological Medicine Strategy for staff care 041520.pdf
Tanya Murtha, MD, MPH, and Andrea Asnes, MD, MSW, Department of Pediatrics, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT provide a simple outline for debriefing medical teams. This is a straightforward and practical approach to conducting such sessions. Submitted April 16, 2020.
Yale Sch of Med COVID Debriefing Guide 041620.pdf
Project ECHO Ontario Coping with COVID (ECHO-CWC)
Dr. Sanjeev Sockalingam, MD, FRCPC, FACLP, of the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, Canada, describes an innovative telementoring approach to providing education and support to healthcare workers and trainees in Ontario. Also included is a description of online resources for healthcare workers.
CAMH ECHO Ontario Coping with COVID 042120.pdf
CAMH Online Resources 042120.pdf
Learning from the Chinese Experience
Two studies, from Dr Zhang and coworkers and from Dr Lai and coworkers in Wuhan, emphasize the severity of psychiatric symptoms among Chinese healthcare workers on the front lines.
Dr Töres Theorell, MD, PhD, Department of International Health, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden, writes a useful editorial about the importance of optimizing work and life conditions for healthcare workers, referencing the work of Dr Cao and colleagues available at the second link below.
“Wellness Rounds” as a Platform to Support Staff Well-being during Covid-19
Dr. Charles Hebert, MD, and Ms. Kathryn Perticone, APRN, MSW, of Rush University Medical Center in Chicago, IL, provide an account of an innovative and comprehensive approach to staff wellness at their medical center. A copy of their flier is also included. Submitted April 12, 2020.
Rush University Medical Center Wellness Rounds 041220.pdf
Rush University Medical Center Wellness Self Care Guide 041220.pdf
More on Psychological First Aid from the University of Washington
Michele Bedard-Gilligan, PhD, MS, Emily Dworkin, PhD, and Kristen Lindgren, PhD, of the Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Trauma Recovery Innovations, University of Washington, provide a guide to Psychological First Aid for improving resilience among healthcare workers, as well as a summary tip sheet. Submitted April 13, 2020.
Univ of Washington Webinar_Increasing-Resiliency-of-Healthcare-Workers 041320.pdf
Univ of Washington Psychological-First-Aid-Cheat-Sheet 041320.pdf
Disaster Psychology for the Covid-19 Crisis
ACLP member George S. Everly, Jr., PhD, FACLP, of The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, offers a comment about disaster psychology and also some related resources. Submitted May 9, 2020.
Johns Hopkins Everly Opinion 050920.pdf
Johns Hopkins Everly Pandemic Resources 050920.pdf
MUSC Program for Healthcare Provider Wellness
Dr. Edward M. Kantor, MD, and his colleagues at the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, send this comprehensive resilience program for healthcare providers at their institution. Submitted May 13, 2020.
MUSC Covid-19 Resiliency Program Overview 051320.pdf
Psychological First Aid Research Update
ACLP member George S. Everly, Jr., PhD, FACLP, of The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, offers an update about research in Psychological First Aid. Submitted June 1, 2020.
Johns Hopkins Everly Psychological First Aid Research 060120.pdf
SUPPORT FOR MEDICAL PROVIDERS – LINKS
Psychological First Aid
The National Child Traumatic Stress Network and the VA’s National Center for PTSD have collaborated on this extensive manual.
The American Psychological Association has a useful webpage on Psychological First Aid.
Study on psychological responses to Covid-19 crisis in hospital workers
This study in JAMA Network Open describes concerning levels of stress in front line workers. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2763229
Some of the better-known apps are:
Headspace: a stress/meditation/relaxation and sleep app free with NPI provider number.
10 percent happier: a stress/meditation/sleep app free to all healthcare providers with code HEALTHCARE.
Slate Magazine: First-Person Accounts from NYC
Slate provides accounts from emergency medicine residents, a hospital chaplain, and family members of hospital providers in the Covid-19 crisis in New York. We add four more striking accounts on April 26, 2020.
Another Eloquent First-person Account from an NYC Hospital
Dr. Helen Ouyang, MD, adds to the record of physician experience in the pandemic.
PowerPoint about Mental Health Aspects of Covid-19
Dr Antoine Beayno, MD, of the Department of Psychiatry, American University of Beirut Medical Center, Lebanon, sends this PowerPoint titled “The Mental Health Perspective in the Current Pandemic.” Submitted April 23, 2020.
Am Univ Beirut Mental Health in Pandemic 042220.pdf
Free Psychology of Happiness Course
Dr Laurie Santos, PhD, an award-winning lecturer in the Department of Psychology, Yale University, offers an 8-hour course in positive psychology and science of happiness.
Free Physician Support Line
A team of more than 600 volunteer psychiatrists offers a free and confidential hotline for physicians on the Covid-19 frontlines. The line is at 1 (888) 409-0141 and operates 7 days a week, 8:00 am to 12:00 am EDT. The project is under the leadership of a steering committee including Mona Masood, DO, Ben Pu Cheng, MD, Allison Cotton, MD, Smita Gautam, MD, and Suzan Song, MD. According to a Medscape interview with Dr Masood, psychiatrists volunteer for 1-hour shifts, and 2 or 3 psychiatrists are available at any time.
Supporting Frontline Health Care Professionals: Lessons from Wuhan Experience
In the April 17 issue of Psychiatric Times, Dr Pu Cheng, MD, describes TopGun Peer Support Wuhan, a project with a team of 45 psychiatrists and mental health professionals offering peer-to-peer support to about 300 healthcare workers in Wuhan. Team members signed up for 2-hour shifts covering a WeChat chat room (WeChat is an app widely used in China, and similar to WhatsApp). The team describes 10 stages of adaptation in healthcare workers and is producing a manual for their approach.
Two Suicides Reported among Medical Providers
An ED attending physician from NYC and an EMS paramedic from Minneapolis have apparently died by suicide, emphasizing the personal stress to frontline providers in the Covid-19 crisis.
An interesting NYT Opinion piece discusses physician perfectionism and the frustrations of the Covid-19 crisis in relation to this physician’s suicide.
PTSD Symptomatology Common among Healthcare Workers in Italy
PTSD symptoms were reported by 49% of Italian healthcare workers, as well as high levels of anxiety, depression, insomnia, and stress, in this preprint from Dr Rossi and colleagues, consistent with other reports suggesting a high burden of trauma will be encountered among our medical colleagues post-crisis.
Psychological Resources from the Center for the Study of Traumatic Stress
Capt Joshua C. Morganstein, MD, Center for the Study of Traumatic Stress (CSTS), Uniformed Services University School of Medicine, sends us this collection of resources.
Dispatches from the Frontlines in The New Yorker
Dr Dhruv Khullar, MD, a hospital physician in NYC, provides 5 inspiring updates in the last month.
New York Times Article Offers Insights into Recent ED Physician Suicide
An opinion columnist at the NYT offers eloquent comments on physicians and perfectionism (the piece also notes the suicide of an EMT in NYC, bringing to three the number of known self-inflicted deaths among US healthcare workers on the Covid-19 frontlines).
McSweeney’s Hosts Flattened by the Curve
Healthcare worker first-person accounts are featured by this non-profit San Francisco-based online publisher.
Society of Critical Care Medicine Survey of ICU doctors, nurses, and other practitioners
A survey of over 9,000 ICU clinicians notes stress levels averaging “8” out of 10 (“3” prior to the Covid-19 crisis).
Physician Burnout, Interrupted
Pamela Hartzband, MD, and Jerome Groopman, MD., offer new insights into physician morale in this exceptional NEJM Perspective.
Boston University School of Medicine CME Webinar on Healthcare Provider Wellness
A one-hour seminar, Care for the Caregivers, Coping in a Pandemic, is available here:
National Guard Front Line Service in NYC for Consultation-Liaison Psychiatrist
Dr. Zheala Qayyum, MD, describes working as an emergency room psychiatrist during National Guard duty in NYC in this moving piece.
Tips for Good Sleep from Sleep Medicine Specialists
Meir Kryger, MD, and Lynelle Schneeberg, PhD, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, talk about maintaining healthy sleep and avoiding nightmares during the pandemic.
New Ways of Supporting Frontline Providers
We noted above the Physician Support Line for frontline doctors. Now a variety of other resources have appeared and offer thought-provoking new approaches. The ACLP provides these links to further a discussion of how to support the mental health of medical personnel: we have no direct knowledge of the quality of any of these clinical service providers.
For the Frontlines offers support for healthcare providers by text chat: send FRONTLINE to 741741 for immediate crisis counselling in the US.
Project Parachute claims to connect frontline providers to therapists in the same state who will provide at least some free care. We note that various commercial online psychotherapy entities have advertised free or reduced-rate care to frontline providers as well.
PeerRxMed offers to pair physicians and other providers with a “buddy.”
Some Facebook pages appear to be oriented to providing support to frontline providers, with some examples being:
Also worthy of mention are webpages from national medical organizations that provide a surprising diversity of resources and links:
The National Academy of Medicine
American Medical Association
American Hospital Association
Incidents Emphasize the Importance of Social Distancing for Providers
At least 17 residents and a fellow were infected at a party in Florida.
Twenty-three employees and 13 patients at a Massachusetts hospital test positive after an employee traveled to a hotspot area.
PATIENT COMMUNICATION AND PALLIATIVE CARE
Yale New Haven Health Goals of Care Scripts in the Covid-19 Crisis
Drs. Rebecca Spear, DO, Auguste Fortin IV, MD, MPH, Laura J. Morrison, MD, Yale New Haven Hospital, New Haven, CT, provides this set of 5 scripts for goals of care discussions, and 3 related documents. Submitted April 14, 2020.
Yale New Haven Health Goals of care scripts 041420.pdf
VITALtalk Guide to Talking with Patients about Covid-19
This is a useful guide for discussions with patients: may be particularly useful to pass on to the medical providers with whom you are working. This group provides useful resources for physician communication: while you are on the website check resources about breaking bad news or end-of-life discussions.
A pdf version is here:
Hospital Policy for Allocation of Scarce Resources from the University of Pittsburgh
This policy may be of use to hospitals developing ICU policies. Unfortunately, rationing of healthcare resources may become essential in some contexts. Having clear guidelines will be critical and lower the burden of such decision-making for frontline clinicians.
Not Dying Alone — Modern Compassionate Care in the Covid-19 Pandemic
Drs. Glenn Wakam, MD, John Montgomery, MD, Ben Biesterveld, MD, and Craig Brown, MD, author this striking Perspective in the NEJM.
FamilyConnect: An Intervention to Improve Communication with Families
Yale New Haven Hospital prohibits physicians of age 65 or greater from direct patient contact in the current pandemic, and will use such staff to aid communication with families and to support busy front line providers. See also the Report from Madrid, Spain from Dr Arango, who notes the CL psychiatrists have taken on a critical role in family communication at his hospital.
Yale New Haven Hosp Family Connect program 042620.pdf
PSYCHOLOGICAL REACTIONS, GENERAL
MGH Guide to Covid-19 Coping
The MGH Department of Psychiatry has put together a curated set of resources related to support and coping for patients, parents, and providers. Some resources are from that department and some are from outside. Their website is: https://www.massgeneral.org/psychiatry/guide-to-mental-health-resources/
Review of psychological responses to quarantine
This review in Lancet covers reactions to isolation interventions.
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health Coping Resources
Another good collection of coping resources is available at:
Online Mental Health and Positive Activity Resources for Patients and Providers
The Psychology Section of the Psychological Medicine Service, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT. offers this list of online free resources.
Yale Psychology – Free Mental Health and Positive Activity Resource List 041020.pdf
Emory University Covid-19-related Handouts for Diverse Patient Groups
Dr. Ann Schwartz, MD, FACLP, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, forwards this set of 17 handouts for patients created by Caring Communities, an interprofessional group based in that department.
Tip sheets from Emory.zip
Large Compilation of Covid-19 Resources
Our member Dr Murali Rao, MD, FACLP, Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Neurosciences, Stritch School of Medicine, Loyola University, Chicago, IL, provides an extensive, curated collection of resources. If you like the ebook, please consider a donation to the National Network of Depression Centers India Foundation to support their production of this resource, as well as their work in developing mental health resources in India and the US(www.nndcifoundation.org/donate).
Projected Deaths of Despair During the Coronavirus Recession
Stephen Petterson, PhD, John M. Westfall, MD, MPH, and Benjamin F. Miller, PsyD, argue that observed relationships between unemployment and suicide / drug- and alcohol-related deaths predict 27,000 to 154,000 extra deaths from the present recession, in this report from the WellBeingTrust.org.
Covid-19 Anxiety Workbook
The Wellness Society offers this non-copyright resource.
The Wellness Society Coronavirus-Anxiety-Workbook 051920.pdf
Meta-analysis of Studies of Psychiatric Effects of Coronavirus Infection Published in The Lancet Psychiatry
Drs. Jonathan P Rogers et al. perform a meta-analysis of 72 studies of the acute and chronic sequelae of SARS, MERS, and Covid-19 infection: post-traumatic symptomatology was highest in prevalence among psychiatric effects, at 34%.
ANNOTATED ARTICLES FROM THE ACLP: SPECIAL EDITION ON COVID 19 AND MENTAL HEALTH
Five Covid-19 Journal Articles Annotated by the ACLP Team
The ACLP provides quarterly annotations for key journal articles, and the January to March batch has just been released: https://www.clpsychiatry.org/educationcareers/annotated-abstracts/
Five Covid-19 articles are annotated here.